Machine, Free Weights, Body Weight Exercises
Which is Best?
Recently, I received an awesome inquiry in my Contact Me form at Straightforwardfitness.com. As I was responding to it, it crossed my mind that I might as well share it in a newsletter so that others can benefit as well. Following is a paraphrase of the question and response. The answer may vary according to a few things such as your specific goals, age, what type of workout you like, physical limitations, how much time you are willing to commit and how many days a week you want to strength train, etc. Since I don’t have that info and I have no idea if you are doing total body workouts or a split routine working certain muscle groups on certain
days, I will have to go with a general answer for now.
Question: If I use a machine like Hammer Strength Row which purports to work all my back muscles, do I need to continue to do Lat Pulldowns and other back machines along with it?
The row (be it Hammer Strength or any other typical equipment manufacturing company) works many of the back muscles, according to which grip you use: 1) palms facing each other with elbows close to the body as you pull or 2) palms facing down with elbows flared at about chest height as you pull. The first grip hits more of the mid to lower back as the second grip hits a bit higher as well. They are both excellent variations of the back row machine.
Watch the first half of
for a demonstration of the aforementioned grips. You can ignore the part where he pulls the handles off and reassembles them. While this is a cool machine, that part is not applicable for my intended purposes here. (I apologize that I do not have a personal video to demonstrate this, but after scouring YouTube, this was the best one I could find.)
I would continue to do the other machines because variety is a beautiful thing. The lat pulldown to the front is a great exercise to couple with the row. If you chose to do only the row every workout, your muscles would eventually get used to it and progress would stall. Plus, it can become boring.
BONUS TIP: Be sure and check out the exercise of the month below for the free weight version of a back row.
Pick a couple of exercises per muscle group so that you hit them from different angles. You might do 2 or
more sets of pulldowns and 2 or more (according to your goals and time constraints) for the rows in the same workout. Or you may even do both grips and 4 sets on the row one day and then the next workout do pulldowns and row. So many ways to skin this cat. lol.
MIX IT UP!
I personally like to mix it up with free weights and machines in the same workout. Free weights and body weight exercises can be manipulated in ways that make them more functional moves, as opposed to machines that tend to isolate muscle groups in a fixed range of motion. Functional exercise is all about mimicking activities of daily living, making them a smart choice along with machines.
If you have never worked with free weights, you may benefit from working with a trainer who can show you proper form and technique. I have a few videos at my YouTube channel showing form with many free weight exercises so you can feel free to check them out. To
strength training routine page
shows a few routines in case you haven't seen that yet.
I hope that helps shed some light on why it is smart to choose a variety of exercises along with mixing up the use of toys such as machines, free weights, body weight exercises, bands, bosu, Swiss ball, medicine ball, kettle bells, TRX, etc. Keep your body guessing by changing things up and you will continue to see results as opposed to hitting frustrating plateaus.
Good luck and don't hesitate to
with any fitness question you may have.
I have decided to extend this great offer I told you guys about last month. I still need book reviews for my latest and I think greatest book, Joined a Gym II. Yup, I dropped the marketing ball on that one after releasing it too. So I am back on track with that; trying to light that fire again also.
If you are interested, you can buy it at Amazon for a limited time offer. I have slashed my price at Amazon from $2.99 to .99 cents for the next 2 weeks. This book is 2-3 times longer than my others because it’s crammed with valuable content.
It’s that simple. All I ask in return is that you go to Amazon after finishing it and give it a review. It only takes a couple of minutes and it will mean so much to me. Come on my peeps! Show me some love! Just
to go to Amazon to buy it.
I believe in this book and I know it would help a lot of people. It’s packed with great info to get the biggest bang for your buck from your time in the gym. I appreciate your support more than you can know!
Alrightie then! I hope you guys enjoy the new and improved SF site. I am enjoying its remodeling and look forward to building it further.
In the meantime, SF’s sister site, my new blog site at
has taken a back seat as I have focused all my attention on getting SF going again. But hang in there ladies! I will pick that ball back up super soonly!
All this because I love you guys and want to help you live the healthiest and happiest versions of your awesome selves as possible!
From my heart to your health,
EXERCISE OF THE MONTH
In keeping on theme, this month's featured exercise is a Bent Over Row. As I said before, I don't happen to have a video of a back row machine, but I do have its free weight equivalent, the bent over row done with dumbbells. Switch this out with the machine now and then for a great free weight back exercise option!
One-Arm Bent Over Row
Primary Muscle Group Worked: Back.
Secondary Muscle Group: Biceps
To see a video of this exercise
Preparation: Place one hand and the same-side knee on an exercise bench, the foot of the opposite leg on the floor, and the hand on that side of the body holding a dumbbell in your hand, hanging at arms length below your shoulder at a slight angle as shown.
Exhale as you pull the dumbbell upward in a slight angle until it touches your lower ribs/outer waist as if starting a lawnmower or sawing. Inhale as you lower the dumbbell slowly to the starting position. Repeat for desired amount of reps. Switch sides and repeat.
Tip: Be sure to keep arm/elbow in tight and as close to the body as possible as you raise the dumbbell. Think good posture, keeping a natural slight arch in your lower back and flat upper back throughout.
HEREIN LIES THE CHALLENGE: Do
not allow elbow to flare out away from the body. Keep it tight and close as you raise the DB up more toward your hip bone rather than your chest (as shown in my vid).
THE PONDER POND
Okay, peeps! You know I usually like to make you think, cry, or laugh with these vids, right? This one goes out to anybody feeling a bit beaten down right now. Hang in there! Above all else...Don't Give Up!!!
to view the video. Enjoy! :)
TO BUY MY BOOKS OR READ MY BLOG
Be sure and check out my blog site! Just
to head on over and give it a read! I will be posting a new blog in the next few weeks.
You can also purchase my books at most of the popular online bookstores in whatever format you may require. Please sign up for my mailing list and subscribe to my blog so that you can be informed when I post a new blog. I am a believer in less is more so don't worry about being inundated with posts telling you every time I had a snack or a new thought. On the other hand, I hope you find the wait between posts worthwhile as I plan to speak directly from my "writing" soul and I look greatly forward to it.
Say! Did you know that you can follow me on Facebook? Well, you can! Jump on over to
and "like" my page, please. I post a fitness tip most days. Feel free to leave comments and check in often. Thanks ever so much! If you have read any of my books you can also go to my new facebook page at
and drum up a conversation with other readers or me or whomever. It's brand new so don't let the crickets scare you. Somebody has to get this party started, right?
Thanks so much for subscribing to this newsletter and for reading it and for your support. Our relationship is reciprocal as I live and learn from all that happens in my life, just as you live and learn through yours. We are truly in this together, and I empathize with your challenges as I do my own. I promise to hang in there and learn and grow along with you, and I hope that sharing through my writing maybe helps you a smidge. If it does, that is my payback. It is why I continue to do what I do.
If you enjoyed this newsletter, please feel free to pay it forward to anyone you think would like it too. That is the best compliment you could ever pay me, and I appreciate it very, very much.
And don't forget to tell everybody about
Now What? Fitness Blog
where they can get all the fitness info their heart desires and sign up for this newsletter while they are there.
From my heart to your health,
Linda Burke, CPT